Menu

Stagecoach Dining
*Prices subject to change without notice
These dishes are great for sharing
Breaded WI Cheese Curds
A Wisconsin must have and our most popular appetizer! Enjoy our regular/plain or spice it up with our jalapeno option. Served with ranch.
$7.95

Onion Rings
Yummy large onion rings, battered and fried to a golden crisp! A great way to start your meal!
$6.95

Breaded Clam Strips
For the seafood lovers, try our battered and deep fried clam strips. Served with cocktail and tartar sauce! Delish!
$6.95

Breaded Mushroom
Whole mushroom coated with batter, deep fried, and served with ranch! For the fun-guy's out there!
$6.95

Chicken Paddles
Enjoy yourself (or share with your friends) ten chicken wings served with ranch.
$9.95

Sauteed Mushrooms
The perfect addition to any steak! Sauteed in butter and served in a bowl with enough to share!
$3.95

Baked French Onion Soup
A supper club and fan favorite classic- homemade baked french onion soup! You can upgrade your soup option or order separately!
$6.00

Sauteed Onions
Yummy mild onion that is sauteed in butter and a great way to top a steak!
$2.00

All dinners include our relish tower with four homemade salads, choice of potato (baked, cheesy au gratin, or homemade french fries) , soup, salad, and rolls and crackers.
Top Sirloin (10 oz)
A fantastic steak that we feature in several of our daily specials that is a naturally lean cut with limited marbling.
$28.95

Filet Mignon (9 oz Queen Cut)
An exceptionally tender steak with a lean texture, and mild, delicate flavor.
$39.95

Filet Mignon (12 oz King Cut)
A steak that takes the ultimate crown in tenderness! Prepared to delicious perfection!
$48.95

Ribeye Steak (14 oz)
One of our most popular cuts of steak with a rich, buttery flavor and tender, juicy texture!
$38.95

New York Strip (12 oz)
Enjoy 12 ounces of this classic, tender, bold flavored steak with exceptional juiciness.
$38.95

Porterhouse (18 oz)
Our largest steak bone-in steak consisting of both a New York strip steak and a tenderloin (also known as filet mignon). For those who are looking for the best of steaks!
$42.95

Steak & Tail
Enjoy our delicious 6 oz filet mignon steak with two succulent 6 oz lobster tails. When you want a little surf and turf!
$69.95
Ground Sirloin (12 oz)
A juicy and delicious patty made from the leanest and healthiest ground beef.
$22.95

Breaded Pork Tenderloin (3 pc.)
An all time customer favorite! Our pork tenderloin is pounded thin in house and hand breaded for the freshest and highest quality!
$24.95

Broiled Boneless Pork Chops (2 pc.)
Our boneless pork chops are grilled to perfection making them a great choice for dinner!
$25.95

Lobster Tails
Treat yourself to two of our rich and decadent lobster tails. Served with drawn buttered and perfectly seasoned.
$49.95

King Crab Legs
Indulge in the luxurious taste of our King Crab, known for its sweet, mild flavor and moist, firm, and rich meat. This one pound of split, tender legs are a true seafood delight, perfect for savoring with melted butter and a squeeze of fresh lemon."
$74.95

Canadian Walleye Fillets
Enjoy two of our delicate walleye fillets, broiled or lightly breaded and fried, known for their mild, sweet flavor and firm, flaky texture.
$32.95

Deep Fried Jumbo Shrimp
Our delicious deep fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce and lemon is a customer fave!
$27.95

Sauteed Shrimp
A tasty shrimp option prepared in a white wine, butter, and garlic sauce.
$28.95

Deep Fried Scallops
Experience the sweet and briny flavor of our scallops, fried to a golden crisp and served with tartar and cocktail sauce.
$27.95

Broiled Scallops
For the seafood lover! Our big juicy, succulent, perfectly broiled scallops served with drawn butter and lemon will make your week!
$35.95

French Fried Lobster (5 oz)
Enjoy a new lobster classic with the combination of five ounces of our succulent lobster, delicately coated and golden-fried to perfection, served with melted butter for a truly indulgent experience.
$34.95

Broiled Cod
Our broiled cod offers a healthier fish option with a mild flavor in a dense, flaky, white flesh. Served with drawn butter.
$24.95

Small portions of our best selling entrees. All come with a choice of potato (baked, cheesy au gratin, or homemade french fries), soup or salad, and rolls and butter.
Breaded Pork Tenderloin (2 pc.)
A huge portion of the highest quality pork tenderloin pounded thin, battered, and deep fried!
$20.95

Ribeye Steak (10 oz)
One of our most popular cuts of steak with a rich, buttery flavor and tender, juicy texture!
$26.95

New York Strip (9 oz)
Enjoy 9 ounces of our fantastic New York Strip! It is the same quality of our dinner, just a smaller portion.
$27.95

Open Face Filet (6 oz)
Same great quality as our dinner version, just a petite! Served on toast points and with au jus on the side.
$27.95

Ground Sirloin (8 oz)
A smaller portion of our dinner patty made from the leanest and healthiest ground beef.
$20.95

King Crab Legs
Succulent 1/2 pound split crab legs
$49.95

Deep Fried Jumbo Shrimp
Our delicious deep fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce and lemon is a customer fave!
$20.95

Canadian Walleye Fillet
Enjoy one of our delicate walleye fillets, broiled or lightly breaded and fried, known for their mild, sweet flavor and firm, flaky texture.
$21.95

Sauteed Shrimp
You can't go wrong with our succulent shrimp sauteed in butter, white wine, and garlic!
$21.95

Broiled Scallops
You can't go wrong with the smaller portion of our big juicy, succulent, perfectly broiled scallops served with drawn butter and lemon!
$27.95

Deep Fried Scallops
Enjoy a smaller portion of our sweet and briny flavored scallops, fried to a golden crisp and served with tartar and cocktail sauce.
$20.95

French Fried Lobster (4 oz)
Enjoy a new lobster classic with the combination of four ounces of our succulent lobster, delicately coated and golden-fried to perfection, served with melted butter for a truly indulgent experience.
$26.95

Boneless Pork Chops
Our boneless pork chops are grilled to perfection making them a great choice for dinner! Served with your choice of potato, soup, salad, and the relish tower!
$22.95

Breaded Pork Tenderloin
Three Tenderloins served with our famous relish tower, choice of potato, soup, salad, and rolls and butter.
$22.95

Ribeye Steak (10 oz)
Served with choice of potato, soup or salad, and rolls and butter.
$25.95

Larger prime rib cuts available upon request for $2.50/oz
Prime Rib (Queen Cut)- Wednesday's Only
Enjoy 9 oz of our signature, expertly, slow cooked prime rib that brings people back time and time again. Served with au jus and horseradish.
$25.95

Prime Rib (King Cut)
Dig into 12 oz of our delicious, slow cooked prime rib. Served with our relish tower, choice of potato, soup, salad, au jus, horseradish, and rolls and butter.
$33.95

Prime Rib & Deep Fried Shrimp
The perfect combination of surf and turf- tuck in for 9 oz of our slow cooked prime rib PLUS four jumbo deep fried shrimp. Served with our relish tower, choice of potato, soup, salad, au jus, horseradish, and rolls and butter.
$35.95

Certified Angus Steak and Shrimp
You can't beat our 6 oz sirloin with four deep fried shrimp. Served with your choice of potato, soup or salad, and rolls and butter.
$22.95

Fish dinners include choice of potato, creamy coleslaw and rye bread. The one night we serve our homemade clam chowder!
Fried Lake Perch
A Wisconsin Favorite! Enjoy our hand battered perch that we fry to a golden perfection with our homemade tartar sauce.
$19.95

Fried Cod
Our mildest fish fillet which we batter in house, deep fry for a crispy crunch, and serve with homemade tartar sauce.
$19.95

Broiled Cod
Our broiled cod offers a healthier fish option with a mild flavor in a dense, flaky, white flesh. Served with drawn butter.
$19.95

Add these items to any dinner! (Cannot be ordered separately as an entree)
Lobster Tail
Treat yourself to a rich and decadent lobster tail. Served with drawn buttered and perfectly seasoned.
$22.95

King Crab Legs
Succulent 1/2 pound split crab legs
$42.95

French Fried Lobster
Five ounces of lobster- cut in house, battered, deep fried, and served with drawn butter. A customer favorite! Try it as an appetizer!
$14.95

Deep Fried Scallops
Get this if you want to add four or our sweet and briny flavored scallops to your dinner or as an appetizer.
$12.95

Broiled Scallops
Add four of our succulent, perfectly broiled scallops to any dinner or order as an appetizer!
$13.95

Deep Fried Jumbo Shrimp
Add four of our delicious deep fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce and lemon to any meal!
$12.95

Melted Blue Cheese Crumbles
Add some zing to your steak!
$4.00

Sauteed Mushrooms
The perfect addition to any steak! Sauteed in butter and served in a bowl with enough to share!
$3.95

Sauteed Onions
Yummy mild onion that is sauteed in butter and a great way to top a steak!
$2.00

All served with choice of potato and a sweet after dinner treat.
Hamburger
A basic juicy, delicious, and made from the best of beef available burger.
$7.95
Cheeseburger
Just what it says...our basic burger with a slice of cheese. Simple and delicious for the younger set.
$8.50
Grilled Cheese
Our ooey, gooey, cheesy, goodness between bread grilled to perfection.
$5.95
Junior Steak
A petite version of our New York strip for the younger set with discerning tastes!
$9.95
Kids Deep Fried Cod (only on Fridays)
Get your tiny human started on their love of supper clubs early with our famous Wisconsin Fry-yay fish fry!
$6.95
Chicken Strips
You can't go wrong with this kid favorite!
$7.50

Everyone needs a little sweet to round off dinner! Our homemade desserts change frequently and are crazy delicious!
Peanut Butter Pie
Our customers raved so much about our homemade peanut butter pie that it has become a staple on our dessert tray!
$7.95

Key Lime Pie
Best key lime pie around! Definitely need to check this out if you love key lime!
$7.95

Variety of Desserts
In addition to our perennial offerings, other popular faves might include- mini cheesecakes (cherry, snicker, or caramel), blueberry lemon cake, peach & blueberry crisp served with ice cream, carrot cake, chocolate lava cake with ice cream, German chocolate cake, or other seasonal sweets.
$7.95

Hand Mixed Ice Cream Drinks
One of the reasons we can call ourselves a supper club! Grasshopper, Pink Squirrel, and Brandy Alexander mixed daily for optimal deliciousness!
$6.50

One scoop vanilla ice cream
If you just need a little something sweet after dinner!
$3.50

Ice cream sundae
One scoop ice cream with chocolate or caramel syrup
$4.95

Anniversary/Birthday CAKE
Let us set up your celebration with a Pepperidge Farm confetti cake.
$12.95

Non-alcoholic Beverages
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Unsweetened Ice Tea, Lemonade, Milk, Coffee
$2.75
We have a wide array of wine for any pallet and price. *Availability subject to change without notice.